By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Immortality (PS5)

Immortality (PS5) - Review

by Lee Mehr , posted on 23 February 2024 / 3,445 Views

Lights, Camera, Action!  While the concept is challenged within Immortality, Writer/Director Sam Barlow has built up an auteur image with a particular FMV template.  They're not simply about indulging in a cache of video clips with some binary choices, but rather in tinkering with an interface, unearthing secrets nested within limited gameplay mechanics, and connecting disparate story threads all the while.  And now the ante has increased in both volume and production value; instead of Her Story's or Telling Lies' desktop video files, now there's genuinely professional film clips during production and rehearsal that emulate their appropriate eras.  While such cinematic appeals will cause some to recoil over its game credentials, the core mystery remains an enticing specifically for balancing on that tightrope.
That main mystery is seen in Immortality's advertising: "what happened to Marissa Marcel?"  This model-turned-actress wound up starring in three unreleased movies: 1968's Ambrosio, 1970's Minsky, & 1999's Two of Everything (2OE for short).  Why did these films never release to theaters and what caused that near-30 year career gap?  You'll uncover this and more through editing software with a simple premise: hitting pause and clicking on any valid intractable – be it person, prop, and so on – within said scene will teleport you to the closest-available match cut across any of the film trio.  What begins as one singular cutscene to watch quickly blossoms into a vast web of footage.

What sounds a bit unintuitive on paper actually makes for an enticing hook.  Not only does it provide a consistent amount of small dopamine hits via investigation, there's this unknown wonder in seeing what's on the other side: selecting a standard crucifix in one freeze frame can transport you to an ornate one covered in blood; further, a still painting in 2OE could lead to a new rehearsal scene in Minsky.  The ways it can zig and zag between eras, visual tones, and story beats with such fluidity feels mind-boggling upon first glance.  Discoveries aren't just made through scene-hopping either.  Like the old 'subliminal messages' trope when playing tapes in reverse, rewinding certain scenes at the right spot will reveal enigmatic superimposed images or sometimes lead to different clips within this film reel.  

This mastery of time and space that lends Half Mermaid's work so much initial inertia.  Like Barlow's previous titles, if you're willing to dedicate the time with a notepad, you'll naturally assume the role of an investigator feverishly cross-referencing leads, character revelations, and filling in the gaps.  Because of these interconnected timelines, the various dramas on- and off-set, and the material itself, my initial notes had so many potential ideas to piece through.  There's this Pavlovian conditioning to acquiring new material and rewinding all the way to the clapperboard (usually) to ensure nothing goes unnoticed.

Once that wave of genuine excitement subsides, the work of collecting later scenes blunted my interest for total completion several hours in – despite piecing everything together before that.  Granted, ennui for any game will eventually develop when you're processing familiar information; that said, Immortality's little annoying things can feel like sizable papercuts for late-game work in a different way.  I have a strong hunch certain scenes are relegated behind invisible walls, despite having familiar match cuts to pluck from, which made finding some integral scenes (like of a killing, for instance) too much of a chore.  Sometimes what seem like valid interactables are just phony – they merely zoom in and then out.  These qualms are exacerbated when you get in the mood to intentionally learn more; the tendency to hop back to previously-viewed reels while you're hungry for clearer answers gets increasingly tedious as time goes on and the rewards feel less consistent.

At least the mere pleasure of watching clips never goes out of style.  Like the elaborate item-matching sequences themselves, Immortality's stars shine by inhabiting roles across different timelines and tones.  From Manon Gage's Marissa to Hans Christopher's John Durick, there are so many minute authentic moments captured between every individual that wouldn't feel as comfortable in another medium.  And, granted, while still meant to be a game primarily, so much of the story leans into the authenticity of scriptwriting, rehearsing dialogue, set design, and all the other qualities in filmmaking for a specific point.  To see every actor act out so many roles – the difference between awkward rehearsal phase, pre-rolling temperament, and standard acting – never stops being entertaining, especially when they ham it up. 

That's what Sam Barlow & co. excel at here: the artistic process itself.  Sure, there’s an understated possession narrative that acts as the glue and genuinely good horror, but the way Immortality interrogates the nature of art, and the potential naked abuses in pursuing it, has the most meat to dissect and appreciate.  I'm keeping details close to the chest and I know these obscure praises would tempt anyone into thinking it's utterly pretentious, but there's more than meets the eye.  The brief windows into these characters off-screen, intermingled with their roles during production, makes for some of the most layered character drama seen in recent games.  Even if the main plot doesn't quite stick the landing (best to ignore the Wikipedia page altogether), those greater qualities surpass its unfortunate flubs.  The added bonus of the three unreleased films, like 2OE's Britney Spears pop era attitude or Ambrosio's salacious religious-themed sex thriller, having schlocky enjoyment in their own right is icing on the cake. 

While Half Mermaid's avant-garde FMV game isn't immortalized in my list of art games, it still earns great respect.  The vigilant dedication to its hidden-object/editing shtick along with an intricate narrative makes for a unique fusion on the art of filmmaking that could only be told in game form.  Granted, betting all the chips leads to a suspicious amount of tedium once you're intentionally scouring for new footage; that said, it's impossible to overstate how enticing everything initially feels when breezing from scene to scene with total disregard.  Similarly, peeling back the layers of this onion deserves more praise than the narrative proper, but the thematic ambitions and avenues it's willing to explore capture something truly special.

Contractor by trade and writer by hobby, Lee's obnoxious criticisms have found a way to be featured across several gaming sites: N4G, VGChartz, Gaming Nexus, DarkStation, and TechRaptor! He started gaming in the mid-90s and has had the privilege in playing many games across a plethora of platforms. Reader warning: each click given to his articles only helps to inflate his Texas-sized ego. Proceed with caution.

VGChartz Verdict


This review is based on a digital copy of Immortality for the PS5, provided by the publisher.

Read more about our Review Methodology here

More Articles

Jaicee (on 24 February 2024)

SPOILERS AHEAD! (Reasons obvious.)

  • +5
Jaicee Jaicee (on 24 February 2024)

"Naked abuse." snickers Yeah, as in so many "great works of art", there is indeed a tremendous amount of nudity in this game, no? :P

One of the most discomforting feelings I've sometimes gotten has stemmed from thinking that after I die, no one will remember me. It's in that little sense that I get why people pursue art and that's why Immortality's weird, quasi-Gnostic-feeling hidden story about The One and The Other was more interesting to me than the surface level one about an actress being consumed by the Hollywood machine. #MeToo the game about the process of being groomed and the audacity of that by itself is a sufficiently interesting backdrop, but the game becomes far more interesting when exploring the spirituality behind how we are implicated (we presumably become The One ourselves in the end), whether and to what extent Marissa is even truly herself from the very start of her journey through film, this sort of layering. Okay yeah, the Jesus and Mary connection felt like definitely a stretch of the imagination, but even this goes along kind of nicely with Ambrosio's set-up aesthetically. :D

Mechanically, a certain amount of tedium also set in for me after I'd collected a certain number of scenes, leaving me to scour material I'd already viewed again and again in the hopes of finding those last hidden links and secrets that remain. Completely get that complaint. But because the game's hidden story is the one that proved more compelling to me, ultimately the game's experimental structure still held together more than well enough for me even from that point, well after the credits had rolled. And while bad art tends to be too on the nose, Immortality runs the risk of being too subtle and subjective for many to really connect to, I think. I get these reservations people sometimes voice and they're certainly fair enough. To me though, the spiritual mystery was more than thought-provoking enough to make up for debatable imperfections in Immortality's very distinctive play structure. Something about it really struck a chord with me and it's that sentiment captured in the scene where The One sings Candy Says; a song about wanting to escape the person they see in the mirror. The raw emotion in Charlotta Mohlin's face as the song goes on is so relatable and captures the fundamental tragedy of art so well. It stopped really being simply a horror game for me after I saw that scene and became something of more enduring impact.

  • +1
coolbeans Jaicee (on 02 March 2024)

Appreciate the response, Jaicee.

I know I was trying to be hush-hush in the main review, so I'll clarify my thoughts more here. I'm with you about 'the others' adding a unique bond with the MeToo and real-life film production segments, especially with how it ties back to the game's namesake for the end. I thought it'd be gimmicky at first, but was sold after the faux-Johnny Carson bit. Such a great sequence. But even with it thematically tying things together, the big snag for me stems back to the plot synopsis itself. My mind was juggling a few theories early on, but then reading the official details for clarity just... don't connect for me. It's one of those weird things where the sequence of events feel wonky or confused in their execution.

Fair enough too! It's a genuinely fascinating template that I'd love to see more games utilize. While more limited in scope, I'm still more preferential towards Her Story's taskbar-scouring b/c everything from concept, pacing, subtle world-building, and so on felt more harmonious. The 'magic' felt more consistent in playing that cold-case detective scouring video files than a film editor here. But perhaps that complexity comes with the territory: the risk of going around a cul-de-sac because some match cuts can look so similar.

It's definitely one worth revisiting with fresh eyes in the future.

  • +1
Jaicee coolbeans (on 02 March 2024)

I don't know how else one could make the role of a film editor more interesting, so I am inclined to view the tedium that eventually sets in as a structural problem that comes with the territory of being placed in that role itself. Or at least it's a problem if you're just some layperson like me anyway. I've seen interviews with professional film editors and cinephiles of a more hardcore bent than me who played Immortality and they seemed to find the game to be their idea of heaven. So maybe it's just that we're not all equally cut out for that kind of work. shrugs But it's a minor problem for me in the end.

There's enough subjectivity here that it certainly won't hit the same and an I think unavoidable late-game drop-off in pacing that doesn't help either, but the concept sells itself, the performances are flawless, and the subject matter was of great interest to me. To me, at least, this is one of the greats. I'd say certainly my favorite FMV game. That's not meant as a slight against Her Story or anything though because it's right up there too.

  • +1
hellobion2 (on 23 February 2024)

Good review!

  • +2
coolbeans hellobion2 (on 02 March 2024)


  • 0
Comment was deleted...