The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom (NS) - Review
by Evan Norris , posted on 10 June 2023 / 5,838 Views
Breath of the Wild is a tough act to follow. Arguably the best video game of all time, the 2017 Switch title ushered in a new era for The Legend of Zelda and set an impossibly high bar for future installments of the franchise. Now, six years later, the development team at Nintendo, including director Hidemaro Fujibayashi and longtime series producer Eiji Aonuma, have attempted to reach that bar, and exceed it. The result is The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, a direct sequel that builds upon the world, mechanics, and underlying skeleton of Breath of the Wild, while introducing more complex physical interactions and DIY opportunities than ever before.
If Tears of the Kingdom could be condensed into a single word, it would be "liberating". The game, by way of its vast open world, creative toolkit, and barrier-breaking locomotion systems, is designed deliberately to enhance player freedom and encourage invention, experimentation, and outside-the-box thinking. There are so many possibilities in this newest Zelda game, whether spatial, chemical, physical, or structural, that it would be difficult to play another action-adventure game — even Breath of the Wild — and not feel somewhat restrained.
All of these possibilities come stacked upon the game’s massive, matchless open world: the kingdom of Hyrule. An enormous landmass defined by multiple discrete climate zones and dotted with towns, forts, fields, rivers, mountains, and deserts, Hyrule is a potent mixture of verisimilitude and approachability. Everything within its borders feels and seems real, thanks to lifelike biological and meteorological systems, but not so real as to deter exploration or interrupt the fun of the game. The Zelda series was built upon the combination of CRPG authenticity and arcade accessibility, and Tears of the Kingdom honors that tradition.
The downside to Hyrule is that so much of it is overly familiar. Because Tears of the Kingdom occupies the same physical space as Breath of the Wild, and features many of the same locations, people, sights, and sounds, it inevitably triggers a sense of déjà vu. The programmers at Nintendo did what they could to refresh all the old haunts, including aging characters, remodeling villages, and adding new landmarks across the immensity of Hyrule, but it’s hard to shake the feeling of "been there, done that".
Gratefully, Hyrule proper makes up only about 50 percent of the game's total explorable space. The other, more exciting half is represented by two entirely new zones: Sky Islands and the Depths. The Sky Island zone, featured prominently in pre-launch advertising for the game, is an extensive system of floating islands and archipelagos thousands of feet above the kingdom. The Depths, shrouded in secrecy ahead of launch, is the enormous subterranean world thousands of feet below the kingdom (think the Underdark from Dungeons & Dragons).
Combined, these two realms accomplish three very important things: they greatly enhance the game's novelty, necessary due to the wholesale importation of the overworld from the game’s precursor; they bestow upon Hyrule spatial freedom and vertical world design never before seen in the Zelda series; and, finally — and this is especially true of the Depths — they recapture the feelings of solitude, danger, and mystery that characterized Breath of the Wild six years ago.
This last accomplishment is especially significant because those feelings are diminished in the overworld in Tears of the Kingdom, at least in comparison to Breath of the Wild. In part this is due to the fact that both games share a map, but it's also because this "new" Hyrule has more signposting, quest-givers, and people than before. It lacks the loneliness that made its predecessor so special.
What this entry lacks in loneliness it more than makes up for in content. Due to the addition of dozens of Sky Islands and the underground world of the Depths, which together basically double the game’s already enormous footprint, there is more to see in Hyrule than ever before. There’s also more to do than ever before, thanks to an overwhelming number of tasks and projects. Tears of the Kingdom boasts 139 side quests and 60 side adventures (meatier versions of quests) in addition to its main quest lines. Compare that to 76 side quests in Breath of the Wild.
Overall, Tears of the Kingdom is one of densest, most content-rich action-adventure titles of all time. Players looking to complete all the main quests and put a significant dent in the ancillary missions should expect to spend a minimum of 90 hours with the game. Completionists can double that figure. Really, you could play it for the rest of your life, considering the endless opportunities for experimentation.
The huge horizontal and vertical sandbox that is Hyrule is extraordinary. It's completely integrated and interconnected, filled with secrets and adventures, and dominated by a heady sensation of discovery. As brilliant as it is, however, the playground tools that Nintendo gives its players to create and craft within the sandbox might be even more impressive. Indeed, this sequel manages to retain much of the experimental potential from Breath of the Wild — oriented around cooking, elemental interactions, weather systems, weapon durability, and more — and add to it via two new powers, Ultrahand and Fuse.
Ultrahand is nothing short of a total game-changer. It allows Link to grab and move objects, rotate them, and stick them to other objects. "With it," says one of the game’s characters, “you will be able to build a great number of things. Really, anything you can imagine." Indeed, the DIY possibilities embedded in Ultrahand are off the charts. You could chop down some trees and patch them together to form a makeshift raft, or you could cobble together pieces of ancient Zonaite technology — gliders, wheels, fans, rockets, batteries, etc. — to create a tank, a hovercraft, or a floating fortress. More simply, you could grab a powder keg and drop it on an unsuspecting Bokoblin.
The freedom to pick up elements in the world and use them to forge bespoke vehicles, equipment, and machinery adds a bold new level of interactivity to Tears of the Kingdom that grants the game endless replay value. It feels very much like a logical extension of, and improvement on, the emergent gameplay that helped make Breath of the Wild an all-time great.
In a similar way, Fuse seems like the next evolution of the exciting improvisational fighting from Breath of the Wild. It allows Link to attach something to an equipped weapon or shield to enhance it in some way. The "something" could be pulled from the environment, like a boulder, icicle, or tree trunk, or from your inventory, for example a Like Like stone or a Moblin horn. Anything you can pick up can be fused to your weapon or shield, resulting in some wild combinations that have the potential to turn the tide of battle. Fuse a piece of topaz to a sword and, voilà, you have a lightning rod. Add a puffshroom to a shield, and watch as the monster that hits it becomes engulfed in disorienting smoke.
While it’s not technically a part of the Fuse power, you can achieve similar battlefield advantages from afar by attaching inventory materials to your arrows. Fasten a Keese eyeball to an arrow to achieve a homing missile, or use an ice fruit arrow to freeze a monster in its tracks. Combat in Breath of the Wild was already an incredibly rewarding tactical affair with room for impromptu decision-making, but Tears of the Kingdom has added to it, layering upon that winning framework additional options to tailor-make your battle plan. The results are phenomenal.
In addition to Ultrahand and Fuse, Nintendo introduces Ascend and Recall, both of which grant Link new movement options that provide quicker, easier movement throughout the game world. Ascend allows him to move upward through solid material and emerge on top of it, which proves incredibly helpful when it’s time to leave a cave or well and you’re not interested in back-tracking to the entrance. Recall, meanwhile, allows him to reverse an object’s movement until it returns to its place of origin. This empowers Link to "ride" broken pieces of Sky Islands upward from the surface. It’s also useful for moving a platform against a strong current or even returning a thrown rock to the sender.
If these new powers seem like a continuation of mechanics and gameplay systems started in Breath of the Wild six years ago, its main questline and the storytelling & dungeons that underpin it seem more like a reversal. Where the first entry in this duology embraced a laissez-faire attitude toward story, allowing players to pick up the trail of breadcrumbs at their leisure, the sequel takes an approach more typical of the franchise, with more exposition, signposting, and direct intervention in general. For Zelda fans who lamented the absence of story in Breath of the Wild, Tears of the Kingdom will certainly seem an improvement. For others, like myself, who enjoyed the original title's roundabout, hands-off narrative, this latest Zelda title rates as something of a regression.
All that said, the story, not to mention the new lore that buttresses it, is captivating and often moving. It all begins several years after Breath of the Wild, in the dusty tunnels beneath Hyrule castle, from which an inky red gloom has begun to emanate. When the heroic swordsman Link and the selfless Princess Zelda go to investigate they find the source of the noxious gloom — a curious mummified corpse, which promptly awakens, drains Link of his power, and tosses Zelda into the abyss. The resurrection of this mummy sends Hyrule castle airborne, opens gaping chasms and a myriad of caves across the surface of Hyrule, and reveals ancient islands in the sky above. Link awakens an indeterminate amount of time after this event, known as the “Upheaval”, to find Hyrule in peril and the Princess still missing.
Because the story in Tears of the Kingdom takes place in the same universe as Breath of the Wild, it represents a special opportunity to reconnect with beloved characters from the first game, now older and in different spots among their peoples. It also gives never-before-seen glimpses into the technologically-advanced, long gone tribe of the Zonai and the origins of the kingdom of Hyrule. Finally, it does the three main characters of the series justice. Ganon is especially evil and sly; Link is dutiful and loyal; and Zelda is brave, kind, and wise. Really, she's the linchpin of the entire game. Not every franchise installment is truly a legend of Zelda, but this one absolutely is.
Just as the game’s story represents a course correction of sorts, its main dungeons appear to be a concession to fans who requested something akin to "classical" dungeons. Each has some elemental theme, a distinct layout and aesthetic, and a completely unique boss, which seems like a repudiation of the copy-and-paste bosses from the Divine Beasts in Breath of the Wild. By the incredibly high standards of The Legend of Zelda, none of the dungeons are spectacular — one wonders if the dungeon-designing muscle at Nintendo EPD has atrophied over the last 10 years — but fun enough. Much more enticing are the long ascents or descents to the dungeons, which have their own perils, platforming challenges, and even mini-bosses.
Everything in Tears of the Kingdom, from its surface and Sky Islands, to its Depths and dungeons, is brought to vivid life thanks to the game’s winsome art direction and visuals. Like Breath of the Wild before it, it won’t blow anyone away graphically, but the anime-inspired soft-texture art style goes a long way. Performance-wise, it's in a league of its own, not because its hits 120 frames per second at 4K resolution — it maintains 30 FPS in all but the busiest of scenes at a humble 900p when docked — but because the game never, ever buckles when so many systems and calculations are running on screen and behind the scenes. This is one of the most physically and mechanically audacious games of all time, running smoothly on the little engine that could - known as the Switch.
Topping Breath of the Wild was always going to be a monumentally tough task, but Fujibayashi, Aonuma, and the legion of artists and technicians at Nintendo came as close as humanly possible with this sequel. In terms of story, structure, and atmosphere, it’s a small step down, but in terms of gameplay systems and depth, it’s a noticeable step up. Regardless of whether it’s superior or inferior to its predecessor, Tears of the Kingdom is a staggering achievement in video game design and programming, and one of the very best games of the generation.
VGChartz Verdict
9.5
Outstanding
This review is based on a retail copy of The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom for the NS
More Articles
Just a absolute masterpiece that improves on almost ever aspect of botw over 100hours in and still loving it.
While the storytelling is definitely an improvement over BOTW, the sense of wonder from exploring isn’t nearly as present this time around. And that was expected, but it was one of the aspects I enjoyed most in BOTW.
But they mitigate this by keeping the player engaged with something new to do every time you make Link turn around. It’s just incredible how many things there is to do in this game in every corners of the game’s world. It’s almost overwhelming at times.
I still think I enjoyed BOTW more, but that’s mostly due to how novel it felt compared to everything else in the series, let alone the rest of the industry, and TotK mostly feels like an iteration on it rather than something entirely fresh.
That’s mostly a nitpick rather than a serious criticism. Because iterating on one of the best games of all time and ending up with such a content packed game is far from being something negative.
For me, BotW was a "love at first sight" game. Tears of the Kingdom is the opposite. The impact is gone, but the more tools I get, the more I explore, and the more I experiment the more I love the game.
Undoubtedly it will take the top spot from BotW for me, but it's interesting how they both became favorite games of mine in entirely different ways.
I really love this game, and I feel you did a great review and summarized aspects of this game that I love perfectly.
Fantastic review, I give it a 10/10
Thank you for this feedback. It means a lot to me :)
I think it's a remarkably big improvement on BotW in most areas.
"For Zelda fans who lamented the absence of story in Breath of the Wild, Tears of the Kingdom will certainly seem an improvement."
I was one who was really hoping for more of a proper storyline in Tears of the Kingdom but so far I've largely seen it as a disappointment. To be fair I haven't finished the game, am probably about halfway done or so, but the fact that the story is more prominent here really emphasizes how weak the writing is. It has massively failed at making me care and that's kinda making the game fall apart from me. I finished BotW in a week but with this game I always feel like I'm forcing myself to go play it, hopefully that'll change
heh. Yeah the timing of Zelda's release wasn't ideal for me, especially when it comes to caring about story and characters. But I do think the game's really lacking in those merits, I've been watching a Skyward Sword playthrough lately and the difference in writing is astounding.
I feel like Skyward Sword has the title of "best Zelda story" pretty much locked up at this point. It's hard to imagine a future game overtaking it.
As for TotK, I do believe the story gets better as it goes. Some of the "tears" vignettes toward the end are quite powerful.
Finished the game yesterday after 115+ hours and there's still so, so much left. Already nearing my third most played Switch game.
I can definitely agree that atmosphere is one area where Breath of the Wild had it beat, but for story while I had gripes with a few repetetive elements in the present day, the memories and the ending really got me. With Zelda games I always end up thinking the story is "suprisingly good", I think I'll have to stop thinking that, they simply tell good stories every time whether it's a major part of the game or more minimalistic.
Gameplay wise it might be the most fun I've had with a game in years, it it's not without its flaws, some that carried over from BotW and a few new ones, but it is something truly special.
9.5 is also were I'd place it all in all right alongside Breath of the Wild. Two giants of gaming to be sure.
I still can't get over how TOTK's main cover has Link doing the "looking through the games on the bottom shelf" pose. Not my og observation, but still love it.
Anyways, a solid write-up emphasizing what makes this a spell-binding timesink.
I am telling you guys, it did feel like I spent 110+ hours in this masterpiece xD
I'd really like a remake of Ocarina of Time and Twilight Princess right now :) I enjoyed Tears of the Kingdom but I put it down for now, will wait for a next gen version of it.
That was after the failed WiiU, and it wasn't a next gen version, as they didn't have to remaster the whole game, it was a pretty simple port, though they did add battle mode. No reason to think they're gonna remaster a game as large as TotK for next gen. They might. But I certainly wouldn't count on it, considering it's gonna get like 25-30m sales and the entire Switch userbase has access to it. Entirely different situation than MK8 coming from WiiU
i hope you are wrong because a new Zelda game is many years away. id love to see a upscale remake with tons of additions on the next system
With tons of additions too?? That's even less likely. I figured you were just talking about a graphical remaster. But you want a ton of a additions to the game too? Seems extremely unlikely. If anything happens, I would think it would just be upscaling Switch TotK on next-gen with the backwards compatibility. I'd much rather have them working on the next-gen Zelda than throwing resources to make a next-gen version in a couple years of a game that just came out.
well for example BOTW and TOTK both have horrid looking trees, just fixing that would be nice, more like the original trailer
In my opinion the only relevant mistake Nintendo made with this game was to believe that the “abilities” had any bearing on what made the BtoW great. And for the second game they focused a little too much on them. But thankfully almost none of that stupid ultrahand building crap is forced on the player, therefore it doesn’t take away any of the abundant fun I am having.
Btw fuse is pretty stupid too, and I absolutely hate, despise and detest how deformed everything looks after fusion.
Recall and ascend on the other hand are cool and useful. I love how they make the game more accessible in a very fun way.
