By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

America - Front

America - Back

Review Scores

VGChartz Score



Alternative Names

フォールアウト 3


Bethesda Game Studios



Other Versions

All, PC, X360, XBL

Release Dates

10/28/08 Bethesda Softworks
01/15/09 Bethesda Softworks
10/31/08 Bethesda Softworks

Community Stats

Owners: 540
Favorite: 41
Tracked: 10
Wishlist: 14
Now Playing: 14

Avg Community Rating:


Review: Fallout 3

By Craig S 05th Dec 2008 | 8,053 views 

Can I write this review without using the phrase ‘Oblivion with guns’?

I’m not so sure I can, but we’ll see how it goes. Fallout 3 is set in a post-apocalyptic Washington DC, and the game starts underground in ‘Vault 101’. So already the game includes two of my favourite storylines of recent years – firstly that of surviving a nuclear war and its aftermath, and secondly storylines revolving around secret underground bunkers (all that was missing was Mamma Cass’ ‘Make Your Own Kind of Music’ - props to the first person to get that). You’re set loose upon the world after you’ve determined your character’s attributes, explored the surprisingly small vault and its annoying inhabitants, and completed a few mini-tasks. The scene you’re presented with when you first leave the vault is impressive. After spending that first hour or so of the game in the relative darkness of the vault, your screen is suddenly flooded with light, and as your eyes adjust to the brightness you see the world for the first time from a brilliant (if somewhat convenient) look-out point on top of a hill.

That view is pretty impressive – you see the wasteland stretching out before you in all its glory. There are ruined bridges, buildings and cars in the distance. There’s absolutely no living plant life, just burnt out shrubs and trees, and there’s rock and debris all over the place. It is 200 years after the bombs that caused this destruction were dropped and humanity is still struggling to re-exert itself, small communities of survivors have banded together for protection and have formed small towns or communities but they’re almost always struggling to survive. That’s perhaps because there are many threats to the survivors, including teams of raiders, super mutants, Enclave troops, robots, ghouls, and some strangely mutated wildlife.

The world is pretty big, and you’ll cover most of the main landmarks while completing the storyline and key sub-quests. When you highlight the quest you want to work on the landmark you have to reach is indicated on the map. If you’ve already visited the location you can fast-travel to it (as long as there are no enemies nearby and you’re not inside a building), whereas if you haven’t you’ll have to start walking. I would have preferred it if you could move faster (it can take a long time to move across the map) and it can sometimes be extremely frustrating when you’re apparently stood on top of the marker on your map but it’s not obvious where you have to go next. I like the idea of not being able to simply transport to a location unless you’ve already been there because it encourages you to explore the world. I would often set off in the general direction of my destination and get side-tracked by something interesting, like a raider camp, a massive satellite dish, or an out-of-place building.

The game is completely open world. As soon as you leave the vault you can go wherever and do whatever you want, although stray too far from the main quest path initially and you will struggle in combat. I feel that this initial informal barrier to the open world theme was a great design choice. You’re gradually introduced to the basics, and then as your level increases and the quests available to you broaden in scope you’re given more freedom to explore the world without too many bad consequences.

Outside of the city that takes up a small central portion of the map the world is quite bland and desolate, there are chunks of rock and slabs of concrete everywhere, and there’s very little going on. It really lives up to the name ‘Capital Wasteland’. If you wander around a bit you’ll probably spawn a small band of raiders, come across a few mole rats or similar animals, spot a few ruined buildings and the odd town here and there, but that’s pretty much it. It’s nice when you do come across something genuinely out of place or interesting, particularly if you’re slogging your way across the wasteland towards your next destination. The city itself is impressive. It’s infested by super mutants, and the ‘boss battles’ with the giant super mutants make for excellent drama, so the city is much harder to negotiate through safely than the wasteland. The buildings are grand and impressive; all tightly packed together, and most have received substantial damage in the war. There’s much more variety in the city than there is in the wasteland - key present day landmarks like the Washington Monument and the Jefferson Memorial make an excellent appearance, and it’s great when you realise that yes, you can go on that massive aircraft carrier that’s in the harbour.

It’s not all good news though. There’s a big pop-in problem, such that as you’re travelling across the wasteland the game is clearly loading textures and objects as you walk. The draw distance is pretty good, although there's a lack of detail in mid-to-long distance objects. You can make out objects in the distance, like the broken railway structures and damaged buildings, but they’re badly detailed and they’re popping in and out as you walk closer or further away from them. There’s a lot of screen tearing as well, I don’t want to include too many spoilers, so I’ll just say that there’s one large laboratory room that becomes the focus of the story for a couple of quests about ¼ of the way through, and it triggers some horrendous screen tearing. Whenever you move the camera in that room the top half of the screen is a mess. The rest of the game isn’t anywhere near as bad as this, but it is noticeable at times. Slowdown sometimes makes a brief appearance as well.

There are sometimes blank textures, although they’re extremely rare, for example I was recently exploring the northern area of the map and came across a large triangular piece of the ground that was just blank – no detail, no colour, nothing. The game’s scale is impressive and that excuses some of these problems – the world is big, freely accessible, and the key landmarks are well realised. But technically the game is poor and there are a lot of nagging graphical issues.

The graphics are solid, if slightly dated by the graphical engine, so don’t expect too much improvement over Oblivion in this respect. Whilst the character faces are clearly improved (in Fallout not everyone looks like a transvestite, for example), they’re all still quite fake and lifeless even when they’re talking. That said, the landscapes are quite impressive and when the V.A.T.S. system is captured perfectly by the camera (which isn’t always the case) the animations and rag doll physics are good, although these graphical benefits are often offset by unresponsive and unreactive enemies. The art style works well, the world is one massive ruin and you can really see that a bomb has hit the place. It’s a great post-apocalyptic setting, but there’s something I can’t quite put my finger on about the look and feel of the game, because although you recognise what the objects are you’re never actually convinced by them; everything is oddly unrealistic.

As for the music, there’s a radio section on your Pip-Boy 3000 which allows you to select a radio station to play as background music, much like in Grand Theft Auto. Unfortunately there are only a few radio stations available, and only a handful of those stations have decent coverage. It’s understandable that this would be the case in a post-apocalyptic civilisation, so it’s in-keeping with the game’s concept, but it does limit the extent to which you’ll use the radio stations. Given that the main radio stations are on a loop and the run-time is short anyway, you probably won’t find yourself tuning in later on in the game unless you spot a new station on the list or you want to hear reports of your deeds in the news bulletins. It’s a good concept, but it could have been better executed. With a longer playtime for each station it would have been an excellent feature, but it feels slightly half-hearted.

Not to fear though, the background music is excellent. Initially you probably won’t notice it, after all there’s a lot to learn so you could be forgiven for not even realising there is background music and the music is very subtle and nuanced, but later on you really begin to notice how varied and interesting the music is. It’s never overbearing and it adapts to your situation perfectly, so for example it’s quite mellow and sensitive when you’re exploring the wasteland, but more upbeat and combative when you’re in danger. The voice acting is good too. Liam Neeson is good as your father, and there a lot of varied characters to interact with over the course of the game. The dialogue works well too, you’re presented with a list of possible lines to choose from and the choices you make do impact on the storyline well.

One of Fallout 3’s major selling points is the V.A.T.S. system of combat. It essentially involves pausing the game to select specific areas of attack. Each body part is given a percentage chance of a successful hit and you’re able to line up a series of attacks. You’re then presented with the results of your attack in a slow motion scene. On the whole the system works well, and it needs to because the ordinary shooter mechanics are pretty broken in Fallout 3. You’ll need to mix up regular shooting with V.A.T.S. because you only have a limited pool of points from which to launch a V.A.T.S. attack, so unless you’re willing to go and cower in the corner waiting for your points to charge up you’ll inevitably make use of the regular FPS mechanics. The problem with the regular shooting is that the accuracy is completely off. You can have a super mutant stood right in front of you with your sights aimed directly at his head and you can still miss. Ordinary shooter fans will find this lack of accuracy extremely frustrating, but even if you don’t hold any particular attachment to FPS mechanics the lack of accuracy is woefully poor.

The V.A.T.S. system works well but it isn’t perfect. Sometimes the camera doesn’t have time to get in position to capture your shots, and in attempting to compensate will move around frantically, often leaving you with some pretty incomprehensible footage. The percentages often seem incorrect as well, and they don’t account for obstacles. So if, for example, you’re firing in-between the railings of a staircase, the percentages will remain unaffected. You could conceivably have a 90% chance of success show up on the screen, but in reality the chance of success for hitting some body parts will be 0% because the railings will be in the way. I quite like the V.A.T.S. system, it works well alongside a regular shooting mechanic because different situations encourage you to use a different approach, it’s just a shame that the level of accuracy for both is somewhat lacking.

As you progress through the game, completing quests, killing things and performing other activities, you’ll level up (to maximum of just 20, which wasn’t enough for my tastes, and I easily achieved this level before completing the game). You’re given a bunch of points which you can then use on 13 different skills, varying from sneaking to your proficiency with energy weapons. On top of that each level also allows you to select one of many bonus perks, which include things like an automatic level up (only available once of course) or more life. This level up system allows for 100s of different variations, particularly when combined with your initial ability base which you determine during your childhood phase. It’s a very versatile system, and it’s one that tends to only enhance your character’s ability to do certain things and doesn’t drastically change the gameplay experience, so choosing to invest in some of the more obscure perks and skills doesn’t end up punishing you.

The 3rd person mode is imported directly from Oblivion, which is unforgivable really. I don’t understand why Bethesda are actually incapable of making a decent 3rd person mode. It feels and plays exactly the same as the 1st person mode, and your character model looks dreadful. Most of my time was spent in 1st person and the only time I switched was in the wasteland, as I would usually be attacked from behind at some point and the 3rd person view gave me a little warning.

The game is pretty lengthy, which is excellent. You can choose to rush through the main story (which in itself is quite short) if you wish but you’re unlikely to want to do that. The main sub-quests really work alongside the main quest, enhancing the story and revealing more about life before and after the war. Then there are the minor sub-quests, which result in much smaller rewards and tend to focus on more minor storylines like particular relationships between characters within a town. These more minor quests don’t impact on the main story, and don’t really add anything to the overarching plot, but they’re there if you want the extra challenge. That said, a lot of your time will probably be spent travelling from one location to another, or fast-travelling back to town mid-journey in order to offload all the items you’ve acquired. The amount you can store in your inventory is quite large compared to your more traditional action games, but given that the journey between locations can be quite lengthy, the amount you can carry quickly becomes an issue, even after you’ve got the perk which allows you to carry more.

Beyond that there are plenty of things to collect, such as the 20 bobbleheads scattered throughout the world. And there are some fun challenges to discover and complete, like planting a grenade on someone without them noticing.

Fallout 3 is a solid game, but there are a lot of issues here as well. The graphics engine is starting to look dated and the game is full of technical problems. There are lot of great ideas that work well but aren’t perfectly executed, like V.A.T.S. and the radio broadcasts, and there are other ideas that aren’t really executed at all, like the FPS mechanics and the 3rd person mode. That said, the RPG elements are well executed, the open world is ambitious (giving you the freedom to explore, whilst at the same time giving you a clear direction and not leaving you to wander aimlessly), and the post-apocalyptic setting is great. Oblivion fans will probably fall in love with the game, and if you invest a lot of time and effort there’s plenty of enjoyment to be had, particularly if you can adapt to the game’s numerous idiosyncrasies.

VGChartz Verdict


Read more about our Review Methodology here

Legacy Sales History

Total Sales

Opinion (103)

1 n/a 176,079 82,113 58,444 316,636
2 n/a 52,413 54,345 27,364 134,122
3 n/a 24,430 28,058 13,664 66,152
4 n/a 16,852 21,161 10,028 48,041
5 n/a 24,203 28,538 13,784 66,525
6 n/a 22,159 40,879 17,536 80,574
7 n/a 32,735 53,604 23,645 109,984
8 n/a 43,843 42,904 22,038 108,785
9 n/a 32,648 44,820 20,701 98,169
10 n/a 14,737 27,923 11,909 54,569
Gluestickid posted 18/03/2012, 03:33
Looking foward to see the next Fallout on Bethesda's new engine!
Message | Report
Aj_habfan posted 03/01/2012, 12:29
Probably my favourite game this gen, so much fun
Message | Report
SolidGear3 posted 18/11/2011, 08:50
Solid 10/10. My favorite game this gen. In 20 years I've never spent so much time playing 1 game.
Message | Report
Iveyboi posted 23/09/2011, 12:00
I will remember this game forever...a game that just stuck with me
Message | Report
Mordred11 posted 02/09/2011, 08:45
one of the best!
Message | Report
yahoocom1984 posted 09/04/2011, 12:41
Fallout 4 is coming!
Message | Report
View all