Monster Hunter: World (XOne)

Monster Hunter: World (XOne) - Review

by Brandon J. Wysocki , posted on 26 February 2018 / 2,548 Views

Though it has deterred some gamers from getting into the series, a steep learning curve and stiff difficulty are intrinsic to Monster Hunter.  In Monster Hunter: World, the essence of the Monster Hunter series has either been preserved or refined – making it the best, most complete Monster Hunter to date.  Existing fans of the series will find an evolved, yet familiar, experience with virtually nothing to dislike.  The only doubt is whether Capcom has succeeded in making the game more welcoming to newcomers.
 
Monster Hunter games use a simple, but effective, gameplay loop – you gather resources while hunting monsters, create better equipment with the parts you receive from gathering and hunting, and then use the better gear to hunt better monsters.  That gameplay loop is bolstered by dynamic, engaging, and challenging combat.


There are 14 weapon types available in the game, each with different pros and cons, that cater to a number of play styles.  The combat is unforgiving, in that each attack is a calculated risk.  Though the combat is in real time, you cannot cancel an attack once the animation has begun, meaning that even some carefully considered attacks, along with most impulsive ones, can at best see you miss embarrassingly, and at worst leave you exposed to counter-attacks.  
 
A new sling shot device can be loaded with a variety of ammo and offers some new ways to approach combat with the monsters.  The ability to mount most of the large monsters is exhilarating and rewarding.  If you can manage to thwart its attempts to buck you off, you can perform a number of weak attacks, eventually opening up a large attack or two before knocking it to the ground, leaving it vulnerable to a short period of sustained attacks.
 
The monsters have no health bar, but rather tells to signify damage.  This can be anything from visible wear and tear on their bodies, including some monsters having parts of bodies that can be broken or severed off (usually good for some additional loot), to monsters drooling, or limping away.  Additionally, the mini-map will display certain statuses and a blinking skull signifies that they’re ready to be captured and/or are close to death.     


Monster Hunter: World’s 14 weapon types have a variety of upgrade trees.  Add to that over 100 armor sets (though not all consist of 5 pieces), and nearly as many charms as you can craft and equip to add or boost skills.  In addition, you can receive “decorations” that can be equipped into slots on high rank armor that can help in the same way charms do.  Armor pieces and weapons can also offer various skill boosts.  In Monster Hunter, you don't level up your character's base stats as you do in most RPGs (though you do increase your Hunter Rank, which simply unlocks more quests).  Instead, your stats are determined by the items you equip once you have earned them from facing tougher monsters. The ability to mix and match armor, charms, and decorations makes for very customizable stats, skillsets, and appearances.  

The plot is fairly simple.  You’re part of the Fifth Fleet, heading to a new continent to help the previous fleets that have already established operations in the “New World”.  After encountering the massive Elder Dragon named Zorah Magdaros, Zorah and the decennial “Elder Crossing” to the New World quickly become the focus.  The story is interesting enough, but takes a backseat to the exhilarating combat, as well as the enticing weapons and armor – the latter two will almost always be the driving force for you to continue playing.
 
Throughout the game, and usually with a bit of plot to back it up, Monster Hunter: World does a terrific job of drip-feeding the content.  As the game progresses, you’re introduced to new locations and new monsters, along with the new armor and weapons to make from the resources you can gain from both.  It’s not that there's an abundance of big monsters, or even hunting locations, but the way they're revealed often feels great.  A number of times, I felt as though I had seen it all, only to find out I had another monster (or variation of a monster) to tend to, or a new location to travel to.


In general, the monsters offer nice variety in terms of their behaviors, strengths, and weaknesses; learning and leveraging those is critical.  One strong point of the series that is as good here, or even better than ever, is the feeling that all these creatures, from insects to the large monsters, are part of a real ecosystem.  At times, the large monsters will engage with one another, which can be both visually striking and advantageous for your hunt.  From watching a Dung Beetle rolling a ball of dung across the map or herbivores grazing, to a large monster hunting or feasting on one of the smaller animals, the world of Monster Hunter: World feels wonderfully genuine. 
 
The different maps in which you can explore and hunt also provide diversity, both in design and in the creatures that inhabit them.  An excellent improvement in this game that veterans of the series will surely appreciate is how each hunting location is now one seamless environment.  Though each map is still broken down into numbered sections, there is no longer any loading between them, resulting in seamless combat and pursuits.
 
The complexity of each map is impressive, though the first location you’ll visit, the Ancient Forest, is arguably the largest and most complex, namely due to its verticality.  All the same, they work with one another to further establish a rich and authentic world to explore and hunt in. 


All of this has been realized with very good graphics (easily the best in the series), and excellent sound design to make the monsters and the world they inhabit look and sound real.  The score for the game is solid, with at least a couple pieces standing out as complimenting the experience.  The writing and acting are very much middle of the road, but I don’t think many come to, let alone stay for, a game like this because of those.
 
All that said, the game is not without its flaws.  Perhaps I’m mistaken, but it feels like past Monster Hunter games did a better job of introducing and explaining the subtleties of the game.  For example, by removing petty gathering quests or quests where capturing the target monster(s) is a requirement from the main (Assigned) quest line, it seemingly leaves new players to stumble upon the benefits of gathering random resources throughout quests, crafting a variety of items, or capturing, rather than killing, monsters.  Indeed, I had to introduce those concepts and benefits to several people I played with.  Removing tutorials via required quests that were a part of past games makes for an immediately more engaging start, but it can be a disservice, namely for new players, because of how beneficial some of these activities and approaches are.


While they have unified single player and multiplayer with matchmaking and a useful SOS feature, in which you can seek help from others whether you’re hunting solo or with a friend or two (most quests allow up to 4 players), or provide help to others who have fired their SOS flare. However, the Assigned/story quests can provide difficulty in playing together, at least for those who are attempting to play the game together from the start.

In past games, single player and multiplayer quests were completely separate.  The execution of implementing multiplayer for story quests is clunky.  Each player has to have reached a certain point in the quest before the quest will be open for others to join.  Similarly, those joining have to make it to that same point in the quest, or have outright completed it, before being eligible to join. 

Some friends and I were trying to complete the Assigned quests, which are essential to unlock new monsters, areas, and so on, but to have to start the same quest separately only to reach a certain point, then backing out (or failing alone) and joining the other’s quest was unintuitive and hurt the flow and feel of the game. 

Similarly, we have found it all but impossible to join one another’s Expeditions from the start, and eventually more or less gave up on doing Expeditions together (the best way to do one together is to complete a Quest together at the desired location, then, when given the option to either stay at that location on an Expedition or return to the central hub of Astera, you and your friends must choose the former).


With only a few exceptions, the missions tend to have similar objectives, though the dynamic gameplay prevents them from feeling repetitious.  Ultimately, if you find the difficult and thrilling combat entertaining, and new and better armor and weapons alluring, there is easily a hundred hours' worth of content here.  For some, especially with the promise of free DLC, there will be hundreds of hours of gameplay.  A small number of flaws barely make a dent; this is the quintessential Monster Hunter experience.


VGChartz Verdict


8
Great

This review is based on a digital copy of Monster Hunter: World for the XOne

Read more about our Review Methodology here

More Articles

3 Comments

AngryLittleAlchemist (on 26 February 2018)

This is a pretty good review and it sums up the main issue with the game well : the bizzaro online system. While online in this game is the best in the series once it gets going, there are a lot of kinks and cracks that need to be fixed, and thinking about how the system makes any sense is like trying to do mental gymnastics. Still, it's a pretty damn great game. I'd probably put it a bit higher on the 8.8-9.2 side myself, but that's just me. Heh, I actually think I have more issues with it than stated in this review, but it's so damn fun.


SpaceLegends (on 27 February 2018)

I wrestled between a 7 and an 8. If you look at our review methodology (there's a link directly below the score), you'll see 8 is about as good as it gets before you start talking about an elite or nearly perfect game. So 8 here may very well be what you're thinking it should be rated.


  • 0
AngryLittleAlchemist (on 27 February 2018)

Actually I have the same scoring system as this site does. So yeah, I did mean a 8.8-9.

I was actually going to write a review, and I was really giddy when I realized an official review had not been out yet. But then literally the day after I got the idea, this review was published x'D. So I've been thinking a lot about how I feel about the game. And yeah, I'd say it's supreme. It has as many issues as any of the GOTY's from last year, and just as much redeeming qualities.


  • 0
Masked_Muchaco (on 19 April 2018)

This is not only the best selling MH game, but also the highest rated. So much for a game that belongs to portables.


PhatChips (on 26 February 2018)

Great game and all, but the repetition sank in quickly


SpaceLegends (on 26 February 2018)

How far did you get in the game?


  • 0
PhatChips (on 27 February 2018)

I've got 40 hours in. Think I'm around the part in the story where I have to kill the first elder dragon. Not that far in the game, I did a lot of side objectives too. Reason of the repetition is probably how each quest takes like a half an hour to complete. Maybe I'm playing it the wrong way because this is my first monster Hunter. I'm not sure. Or just not something for me. I'll still play it here and then, but not too much.


  • 0
SpaceLegends (on 27 February 2018)

Yeah, a hunting or capture quest usually takes 20-30 minutes, unless you do an Investigation that has a 15 minute time limit, in which case the monster will have reduced health. I skipped a lot of optional quests, and instead focused on completing the story quests (to unlock more areas and monsters) and/or would try to hunt monsters based on specific weapons or armor I was looking for. To a large extent, I feel like the game only just begins when you beat the first elder dragon, although I think I saw a few outlets base their review on the game to that point.

All the same, not everyone will be a fan. I love the stiff challenge, particularly when trying to hunt monsters that are probably out of my weightclass at the time. And the sweet, sweet, loot gives me reason to go back and do again and again. Even though I've hunted every monster in the game, and essentially have my ideal "loadout," I still find it fun to go on hunts, as there a few items I'm still hoping to obtain. I also find it fun to help others with their hunts, namely because I do enjoy the combat in the game.


  • 0