By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
A Look Back at Titanfall, the Best (and Most Polarizing) Shooter of the 8th Gen

A Look Back at Titanfall, the Best (and Most Polarizing) Shooter of the 8th Gen - Article

by Evan Norris , posted on 27 October 2016 / 11,141 Views

With Titanfall 2 due out tomorrow, it seems like a good excuse to revisit the 2014 title that started it all. The original Titanfall first appeared on the national radar at E3 2013, where it quickly became a critical darling. It won over 60 awards, including an unprecedented six E3 Critics Awards. Amongst the gaming community, though, the reactions were more mixed. Some saw it as deliverance from an increasingly stale and safe genre. Others dismissed it superciliously as "Call of Duty with mechs."

What explains the divergence in opinion? First-person shooter fatigue surely played a part. Yet just as real estate is all about "location, location, location," all too often video games are about exclusives, exclusives, exclusives. The fact that Titanfall found a home on PC, Xbox One, and Xbox 360 — and not PS4 — rubbed some fans the wrong way. As a result we saw many Xbox fans championing the game as the Second Coming, and many PlayStation fans doubting its quality and appeal.

Titanfall titan

So, over two years later, who was right? Well, both sides in a way. On the commercial front, Titanfall failed to capitalize on the enormous level of hype surrounding the title in the months leading to launch in March 2014. Forbes' Paul Tassi wrote in April that "very shortly after release, the buzz seemed to fade abnormally quickly."

The exact number of units sold across three platforms is difficult to discern — developer Respawn boasted of 10 million unique players and Electronic Arts CFO Blake Jorgensen stated "a little more than 7 million units". Our estimates currently put it just shy of 5 million sold at retail. Regardless of the actual figure it's safe to say that Titanfall was neither the blockbuster hit nor the Xbox One "killer app" that many anticipated.

Titanfall pilot

Why did Titanfall's buzz drop precipitously in the months after launch? I'd argue it hinged on two factors: lack of modes and zero offline content. Although a large number of modern gamers enjoy broadband internet and are accustomed to playing online, many remain wary of online-only games. Server support is finite and can end suddenly. Look at Dead Star, which is losing server support on November 1 after only seven months on the market, leaving only the tutorial playable.

The fact that Titanfall launched with only five modes — all multiplayer —also hurt post-launch momentum. A proper single-player campaign would have done wonders, as would a co-op mode or a free-for-all competitive mode. Extra content, including "Frontier Defense" — an addictive co-op mode inspired by Gears of War's "Horde" mode — and "Deadly Ground" did arrive eight months after launch, but it was a case of too little, too late.

Titanfall map

So on the commercial side of things, the Titanfall detractors were more or less correct. In terms of quality, though, the Titanfall believers found their faith justified. Put simply, Titanfall is one of the most inventive and engaging shooters in years, a must-have title for Xbox One owners, and the all-around best first-person shooter of the eighth generation (so far). Why is it so good? Well, the answer, paradoxically, has a lot to do with why many players ignored or forgot the game: the singular focus on competitive multiplayer.

Respawn's deep focus on multiplayer allowed the studio to forge one of the most accessible and balanced shooters in a generation. Staffed with industry veterans who had worked previously on Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare and its sequel, Respawn was able to draw on its past experiences and pave a road toward the future of the genre, focusing on player mobility, survivability, and the merger of single-player tropes with multiplayer action.

Titanfall smart pistol

On the mobility front, Respawn scored a home run. Titanfall's pilots are fast, agile, and capable of dashing across maps like a ring-tailed lemur. The game features maps that are impressively large, vertical, and open for exploration — a far cry from the plodding, mostly-flat maps in rival shooters. Titans are of course bulkier and slower but add even more flavor to each match.

Equally important was survivability. Titanfall producer Drew McCoy explained a few months after the game launched that Respawn "looked at how you increase a player's life span without reducing the lethality of it, because that time from to kill to kill is one of the big hooks. Players like getting constant kills — they don't like being killed constantly." Enter Titanfall's much-maligned AI bots, which ease novice players into the game and act as a buffer of sorts between opposing pilots.

Titanfall shield

Last but not least, Respawn infused elements common to single-player campaigns into Titanfall's competitive multiplayer. With cinematic introductions, AI soldiers dotting the landscape, and an epilogue that follows every victory and defeat, each match feels like a small battle in a much larger war. Even a loss can feel like a live-to-fight-another-day scenario.

Although Titanfall failed to reach EA's lofty sales expectations and moved far fewer Xbox One units than anticipated, it stands today as a shining example of the first-person shooting genre. By drawing in creative minds and focusing deeply and intently on a single concept — competitive multiplayer — Respawn created the heir apparent to Modern Warfare, and by prioritizing mobility, survivability, and immersive single-player "moments," forged the most disruptive shooter since 2007.

More Articles

starcraft (on 27 October 2016)

I can't believe we're implying 7 million sales is a commercial disappointment!

  • +4
Veknoid_Outcast starcraft (on 27 October 2016)

Remember that Tomb Raider (2013) sold 3.4 million units in four weeks but Square Enix labeled those numbers disappointing because they failed to cross the anticipated threshold. It's not always about gross numbers.

  • 0
starcraft starcraft (on 27 October 2016)

Sure, but that in itself is insane. Its a large part of why and how we see so many studios failing these days.

In this case, ultimately EA were clearly content with the numbers, and the game was commercially successful.

  • 0
Veknoid_Outcast starcraft (on 27 October 2016)

You're not wrong. It's an unfortunate side effect of the "AAA" business model.

  • 0
starcraft starcraft (on 27 October 2016)

Agreed. I don't know what the answer is. I love AAA experiences with a strong story and single player like Tomb Raider and Uncharted. In some respects that makes me part of the problem.

  • 0
Ka-pi96 starcraft (on 29 October 2016)

Square Enix probably arent a good example when it comes to sales expectations. They always seem to expect much more than is realistic. Wouldnt be surprised if FFXV sells like 10m this year and SE will still call it a disappointing launch :P

  • 0
starcraft starcraft (on 30 October 2016)

Amen to that Ka-pi.

  • 0
shikamaru317 (on 27 October 2016)

I enjoyed Titanfall 1, but it definitely didn't have enough multiplayer content at release, which resulted in the massive player drop-off rate. From what I've heard Titanfall 2 seems to have alot more content, so hopefully it will have the longevity that the first game lacked.

  • +2
Seventizz (on 29 October 2016)

TF1 is easily my favourite new IP this gen. I still play regularly on Xbox One. Sadly, it's sequel isn't as good multiplayer wise.

  • 0
WoodenPints (on 28 October 2016)

Titanfall is definitely enjoyable but was rather hard to keep track of what was going on in the campaign playlists at times with playing different sides of the story and maps out of order but after doing it all I was happy with it.

  • 0
Mr Puggsly (on 27 October 2016)

It wasnt really polarizing. It was a fun online shooter and reviewed well. If you enjoy online shooters, its hard to dislike.

  • 0
Aidah (on 31 October 2016)

I thought the game was okay at best. Not the best anything really.

  • -1
Ben360live (on 28 October 2016)

I thought it was great fun at launch. My biggest complaints personally were the massive amount of bots compared to actual players and the lack of a single player campaign. Gameplay was excellent though...

  • -3
Azuren (on 28 October 2016)

Well, I don't like it because I like campaigns. But I also don't care much for shooters, so fuck me, right? Also, the best of 8th Gen? Pretty sure that goes to Overwatch.

  • -4
Seventizz Azuren (on 29 October 2016)

Stick to 'not caring much for shooters', because Overwatch is not the best shooter of this gen. Titanfall 1 is.

  • +1
Azuren Azuren (on 29 October 2016)

Which is why people just won't shut up about Titanfall, right?

Oh wait, they did.

  • -3
Ka-pi96 Azuren (on 29 October 2016)

Says he doesnt like Titanfall because it didnt have a campaign... claims Overwatch is best shooter of the gen.
You get the irony right? :P

  • 0
Azuren Azuren (on 29 October 2016)

I don't care for Overwatch, either, I'm going off of numbers and how it's managed to stay relevant longer than a week past release.

  • -3
Raistline (on 27 October 2016)
  • -6