By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Xbox Game Studios was the Highest Rated Publisher in 2021 on Metacritic

Xbox Game Studios was the Highest Rated Publisher in 2021 on Metacritic - News

by William D'Angelo , posted on 09 March 2022 / 3,135 Views

Metacritic as part of its "12th Annual Game Publisher Rankings" has revealed Xbox Game Studios was the highest rated publisher in 2021. This is up from sixth place in 2020.

Xbox Game Studios had 10 scored products with five distinct titles. The publisher had an average Metascore for 2021 of 87.4 with three "Great" games.

"It is very rare for a publisher to average above 80 for its releases across a single calendar year," reads the post from Metacritic. "But how often does a company average above 85? Never ... until this year.

Xbox Game Studios was the Highest Rated Publisher in 2021 on Metacritic

"Our runaway winner of this year's Publisher of the Year honors, Microsoft certainly published fewer titles in 2021 than it does in a typical year. But what games it did publish were uniformly excellent, making Microsoft the only publisher with a 100% success rate.

Three different titles scored 90 or higher (also tops among all publishers): the latest Forza Horizon racer, a sequel to Psychonauts, and the Xbox Series X version of Microsoft Flight Simulator. Their successes almost make Halo Infinite seem like a disappointment with a mere 87.

"Can Microsoft maintain its quality control once Activision Blizzard is welcomed into the fold? Stay tuned."


A life-long and avid gamer, William D'Angelo was first introduced to VGChartz in 2007. After years of supporting the site, he was brought on in 2010 as a junior analyst, working his way up to lead analyst in 2012. He has expanded his involvement in the gaming community by producing content on his own YouTube channel and Twitch channel dedicated to gaming Let's Plays and tutorials. You can contact the author at wdangelo@vgchartz.com or on Twitter @TrunksWD.


More Articles

15 Comments
rapsuperstar31 (on 09 March 2022)

Thanks for linking it right to the relevant page, I hate articles that make you click the next page link 31 times to get to the winners page. Great year for Microsoft, and it didn't even mention Deathloop and it's 88 average review score.

  • +10
G2ThaUNiT rapsuperstar31 (on 09 March 2022)

Yeah, Bethesda was ranked 5th and is still viewed as a separate publisher. Seeing the releases this year, at least so far, Bethesda may end up ranking higher than XGS this time next year lol

  • 0
LudicrousSpeed (on 09 March 2022)

Fun fact, MS also owns Bethesda, which for some reason was ranked separately from MS as the fifth best publisher, and will soon own Act/Bliz, the fourth ranked publisher. So basically GamePass wins.

  • +6
Signalstar (on 09 March 2022)

Congrats to Microsoft. Way to turn things around!

  • +2
Azzanation (on 09 March 2022)

Bloody GamePass ruining our quality games.. oh wait, it isnt. But people on the internet said it would.

  • -1
method114 (on 09 March 2022)

Comparing 5 games to 10. Seems fair.

  • -4
G2ThaUNiT method114 (on 09 March 2022)

XGS had 10 total releases in 2021 that had a rating on Metacritic, but 5 of them were just that high. Age of Empires IV was part of those 10 releases, but it had a lower score of 81 on Metacritic. I imagine the rest were DLC or expansions of some sort that got their own Metacritic rating.

  • +2
JWeinCom G2ThaUNiT (on 09 March 2022)

No, it clearly says "5 distinct titles". Which seems to mean that at in addition to having fewer games to manage, at least a few titles were counted multiple times. Really not a great methodology.

  • +3
G2ThaUNiT JWeinCom (on 09 March 2022)

So what, are the other 5 not included in this overall ranking and only include MS Flight Sim, Psychonauts 2, FH5, Halo Infinite, and AoE4? Because they clearly say "10 scored products" in 2021.

  • 0
JWeinCom G2ThaUNiT (on 09 March 2022)

My understanding is that the ten scored products include multiples of the same game. As in, Psychonauts 2 for XBox and PC are each counted in the score.

  • 0
Comment was deleted...
G2ThaUNiT Bandorr (on 09 March 2022)

Can't comment on the second part lol but Xbox Game Studios is the overall brand name for Microsoft's gaming division. There is nothing else other than Xbox Game Studios since it got rebranded as such in 2019. Age of Empires 4 is a first party Xbox IP even if it's not on an Xbox console.

  • +4
Comment was deleted...
G2ThaUNiT Bandorr (on 09 March 2022)

Yeah, that was partly the reason why the rebranding so as to avoid confusion. Everything gaming related under the Microsoft umbrella is now unified under the Xbox Game Studios division. But Xbox Game Studios does have a corporate hierarchy still, which is Microsoft Gaming, which oversees all of Xbox Game Studios, Bethesda, and soon Activision Blizzard. Which Phil Spencer is CEO of, and they then answer to Microsoft directly.

Think of it as how PlayStation Studios answers to Sony Interactive Entertainment who then answers directly to Sony.

  • +1
Comment was deleted...