VGChartz Pro

E3 2010: Game of the Show Awards!

by Nick Pantazis, posted on 21 June 2010 / 14,198 Views

E3 was absolutely incredible this year, and while we're still posting up our hands-on articles and previews from our busy week, we did sit down at the show and go through the games that impressed us the most. These awards represent our opinions and impressions on our favorite games of the show. While we played hundreds of games we didn't play everything, so opinions may vary. However, above all else we hope these awards will highlight some of the truly stand-out titles, and give you some games to look forward to. So without further ado, I present to you VGChartz's favorite games of E3 2010.

Bulletstorm


Bulletstorm looks like an over-the-top violent marriage between Epic’s own Unreal Tournament and Madworld. The game is a first-person shooter with cover mechanics and the tagline "kill with skill".  Bulletstorm doesn't want you to kill with efficiency, but would rather you act like a cat playing with a mouse before the kill.  Every demented action you inflict on a person like kicking them into a cactus or using your grappling hook to toss them into the air is rewarded with points.  You're encouraged to string a long list of deplorable deeds together to increase your score.  It's a lot like Madworld sped up to the pace of your typical FPS.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Twisted Metal


David Jaffe is officially the biggest tease in the gaming industry.  After telling everyone and their mother that he wasn’t going to step foot in E3 and he wasn’t working on Twisted Metal he rides in with Sweet Tooth at Sony’s E3 conference.  Luckily Twisted Metal is completely worth getting jerked around for.  VGChartz got a chance to play this on the floor today and it is shaping up to be exactly what the fans have been waiting for.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Gran Turismo 5


Gran Turismo 5 took home the gold for racing games among fierce competition at E3 this year. This sim racer has a ridiculous level of detail, variety, and options that make it a must own for any hardcore sim racing fan. In addition to this a ton of new social networking features, 3D, head tracking, and multidisplay truly make Gran Turismo stand out among the competition. The top of the line of sim racers is finally here… almost.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.


Deus Ex: Human Revolution

The demo drew to a close with Jensen confronted by an extremely powerful augmented human, whose arms could turn into enormous guns. It was a blast to watch, and alleviated any apprehension I had that it wouldn’t meet what I expected of a Deus Ex game. If this demo is any indication it will be a true evolution for the franchise. Deus Ex: Human Revolution is a true Deus Ex game, and so far looks like an incredible experience for fans and new players alike.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Mortal Kombat


That is how you do a Mortal Kombat game.  That is how you kill an enemy at the end of a hard-fought battle.  That... is Mortal Kombat.  The series has endured bankruptcy, plenty of less-than-stellar titles, and years of silence (Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe doesn't count!) to become the most emotional experience I had on the floor.  I haven't literally cringed, gasped, or laughed aloud in wonder at something on a game screen in a long time.  Bravo, Warner Brothers.  You did the MK name proud.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.


The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword


The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword was a cavalcade of varying motion controls of all types on the Wii, and a truly impressive demonstration of its capabilities. While clearly the visuals are still being polished, you couldn't ask for smoother gameplay. If this is the future of motion controlled action games, count me in, and if you really want a 1:1 sword control adventure, look no further. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword is shaping into an incredible experience.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.


Civilization V


Civilization fans have been waiting since 2005 for the next major installment in the beloved strategy game of world conquest. With Civilization V the developers (Sid Meier's Firaxis studio) have completely re-thought the experience that is Civilization, introducing new features in an attempt to make the game both simpler to play but deeper to master. I got a chance to attend a live demo of the game here at E3 and let me tell you, Civilization is back in a big way.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.



NBA Jam


All of the classic arcade gameplay features combine to make a game that feels like NBA on crack.  Few rules, very fast pace, ridiculous facial expressions and animations on the characters, and the ability to play as characters like team mascots—it’s every bit as exciting as it sounds.  Is it any wonder that everyone in line behind us was shouting, gasping, and screaming at every twist in the game?

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Kirby's Epic Yarn

Kirby's going back to his roots, platforming on a home console for the first time since the year 2000.  His eating attack has been replaced with a whip of yarn, and the whole Dream Land has been replaced with a world of yarn, cloth, and buttons.  Kirby jumps, drives, parachutes, skateboards, swings, ground pounds, and whips everything in sight.  Then he turns into a shark, a submarine, a car, a UFO, and a giant tank that shoots boxing gloves.  Reggie definitely wasn't kidding when he said Kirby's got game. 

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Dance Central

Wait? What? A dancing game where you actually dance?! Yes, we’re serious, and Dance Central seriously rocks. It’s easily the best use of Kinect we saw at all of E3. There is nothing more important for full body motion capture than dancing, and in our experience Dance Central plays like a dream. Brought to you by the great developers behind the original Guitar Hero and Rock Band, Dance Central stands out among the oversaturated music genre.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Or watch our own Evan Elden Eller rock out to Dance Central here.



Portal 2

At the end of the event, Valve concluded by stating that the original game had received a lot of warm reception and praise for its ending theme song, Still Alive, and that they’d like to replicate that success in some shape or form in the sequel if given the opportunity.  It was emphasized that the new single player will be twice as long as the first game and that co-op would feature an entirely different set of levels from the single player mode.  We at VGChartz can’t wait to see what the sequel looks like in its final form when it ships next year.  If it’s anything like the E3 2010 build, then we can consider ourselves very happy.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

 Wii Party

The first mode, and the only one I had a chance to play, resembles the Mario Party series. Four competitors (comprised of human players and computer characters if there aren’t enough human players) compete on a board-game overworld. Each round order is determined by a mini-game, and advancement is made by rolling dice. The higher you place in the mini-game, the better your second die will be. The mini-games are pretty standard for the Mario Party series, but they remain fun. Bumper Balls has been updated with motion controls and has become a faster and more frenetic game. The Board Game mode is a fully realized party game by itself, but according to Nintendo there is more.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

EA Sports Active 2

The hardware you receive will be dependent on the console you purchase it for. The Playstation 3 will have three sensors (two will strap to your arms and one to your leg), the Wii will have ship with two sensors (one will strap to your arm and one to your leg, the Wii remote will be the sensor for your other arm). As for the Xbox 360, it will not ship with any sensors; instead it will require a Kinect. EA Sports Active 2 is the best at identifying and communicating exercise routines I have seen since ‘exergaming’ became a genre.

Check out our full E3 Preview here

Star Wars: The Old Republic


Star Wars: The Old Republic has us more interested than any MMO we’ve ever seen.  The combat looks promising if the glitches are ironed out, every player’s decisions affects the galaxy, and the voice acting is just superb.  After the debacle with Star Wars Galaxies, we had a bad feeling about this when LucasArts announced a new MMO in the series.  However, what we saw, despite some flaws, left us thoroughly impressed and wanting to play more.  The force is strong with this one.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

LIMBO

Playdead Games is a small team consisting of eight core members (16 members at its peak), and LIMBO proves that these small studios can show the mega-developers how a single simple vision can speak volumes. This title is a downloadable game that will release at 1200 MS points, like all ‘Summer of Arcade’ games, and its more polished than some of the Xbox 360’s full retail offerings. The visuals, the sound, and the gameplay are all great tastes that taste great together, and there's no HUD, no score, no health bar, or any of that traditional gaming stuff to get in between you and the very unique, creepily atmospheric experience.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Child of Eden

Child of Eden rocketed to the top of our list with a stunning trailer that sadly went almost completely unnoticed because it was only shown once the entire show, and that was at the Ubisoft conference. The game was nowhere to be found on the floor or in either the Move or Kinect booths, which is disappointing as it seems to be one of the most impressive applications of either device. Fortunately for you, VGChartz is here to save the day, getting the word out on this gorgeous and artistic game from Tetsuya Mizuguchi, one of the most talented designers in the industry. Be sure to check out the trailer in the link below, and see why we feel this easily deserved best visuals.

Check out the trailer for Child of Eden here.

Child of Eden/Kid Icarus: Uprising

Tetsuya Mizuguchi is making another game? What’s that you say? It’s another rhythm action game? Yes please! Child of Eden takes a second award, but shares the spotlight on this with the shocking announcement of Kid Icarus: Uprising. A new Kid Icarus game has long been rumored, but no one expected it to be a 3DS launch title, or for it to look so great! These two shocks managed to tie for our award, as picking just one of them would have torn our team apart, so congratulations to both of you for giving us the kind of surprises we look for at E3!

Check out the trailer for Child of Eden here.
Check out the trailer for Kid Icarus here.

Kirby's Epic Yarn

There were a lot of innovative new titles this year, and we started to notice a trend: many of the hottest new gameplay features involved changing the game-world while playing within it.  This was the case with Disney's Epic Mickey and its paint thinner, Shaun White Skateboarding with its mid-grind rail-creation, and even Ivy the Kiwi?'s ability to draw, rotate, and stretch platforms all over the map while running all over them.  But it was Kirby's Epic Yarn and its perfect marriage of visual innovation and gameplay innovation that stole the show for us.  If a jump is too far to make, you can pull the other side towards you with your whip.  If a secret is too high to reach, you just grab some of the cloth background with your whip, and pull the whole sky down a little bit.  We never thought we'd see such crazy sci-fi concepts as "space-folding" ever look so cute and cuddly, but it just works.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit

Despite consistently solid sales, the Need for Speed franchise hasn't really shined since the Most Wanted back in 2005. Criterion captured the hearts for race gamers and critics alike with Burnout Paradise and it set to do it again with the Need for Speed IP. The game handles much like Burnout Paradise, though the cars had a big more weight to them so the cars had more reactive control.  The game is very fast. NFS: HP creative director, Craig Sullivan, told us he didn't see the point in including slow or low-end cars. This leads to a big collection of rare and very high-end machines.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit

While the gameplay was great, it wasn't even the best part. Criterion is hard at work building a type of social networking right into Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit. Sitting on the main menu (sorry, no pictures allowed), notifications come falling down the screen of what your friends have been doing in the game since last you logged on or even while you were in your last race. This new system is called "Autolog." You can easily see when a friend has broken your record time or high score and immediately choose to challenge it through an intuitive recommendation system. Best of all, all this sharing doesn't require you to log into Facebook or Twitter so you don't have to pester your non-gaming friends with all your newest Hot Pursuit accomplishments.

Check out our full E3 Preview here.

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

It was an incredible E3, full of incredible games, and the debate over what should recieve our highest honor of the show was lengthy and brutal. So why did Zelda, despite being so clearly incomplete, win it? It won on gameplay alone. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword has some of, if not the best motion controls on Wii. Nintendo really nailed it on this one, and delivered on all the anticipation of millions of fans for a sword fighting game with 1:1 controls. It's simply incredibly fun to play, and an experience that we didn't find anywhere else. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword is our Game of the Show!

Check out our full E3 Preview here.


Related Articles

52 Comments

DanielD (on 05 July 2010)

I think most people underestimated Zelda.


Severance (on 02 July 2010)

Bulletstorm best shooter? its very average! and rythm game is dance central ? not Rock band 3 ?


MARCUSDJACKSON (on 23 June 2010)

nice


naznatips (on 23 June 2010)

@ benao Yes, just as music games are. Fitness games are the fastest growing genre in all of gaming. Scary as that may be, they've easily earned their own category.


Rainbird (on 23 June 2010)

My only complaint is that you didn't include runner-ups, I would have loved to have seen those. Good job otherwise :D


benao87 (on 23 June 2010)

So now, Fitness is a whole genre? Uhmmm


guiduc (on 22 June 2010)

DK :'( But great comeback for Kirby! Also, astounding graphics for Gran Turismo 5... I'm impressed.


The Ghost of RubangB (on 22 June 2010)

Also, Biggest Comeback was probably the hardest vote. If I had my way, it would've been a 6-way tie between Donkey Kong Country, Kirby, GoldenEye, NBA Jam, Mortal Kombat, and Kid Icarus. But all the Need for Speed guys took me out back, smacked me around a bit, and cut off one of my toes.


Torillian (on 22 June 2010)

@those who want LBP2 to be the winner for most innovative I saw LBP2 played by Alex from Media Molecule for an hour and I also got around an hour to play it myself and I loved it. But I felt it wasn't the most innovative at the show because it's a continuation and refinement of the idea behind the first LBP. LBP2 will be alot of fun and a number of the features are very innovative in how they're implemented but the overall idea is still the same as LBP2 so we felt Kirby was more innovative as an entire game.


*Sound Of Rain (on 22 June 2010)

My game of the show is Kirby's Epic Yarn easy.(If Pikmin 3 had even a 10 second trailer this would probably be different)


SuperAdrianK (on 22 June 2010)

Go Kirby!!!


TX109 (on 22 June 2010)

LOL @ the people who didnt play the games who are complaining. OT: i think its a good list. i dont agree with NFS: HP being biggest comeback, but thats just me. the biggest comeback IMO was Kid Icarus. oh well, like i sadi, good list.


The Ghost of RubangB (on 22 June 2010)

Hey all Kirby has is a whip. Link has a whip AND a flying beetle, a sword, a shield, a bow, a slingshot, and who knows what else this time. The whip, beetle, and sword controls are what made it Game of the Show for me. My personal runners-up for Game of the Show were LIMBO and Mortal Kombat. As for Donkey Kong Country Returns, it was definitely a close runner-up for best comeback and best platformer, and it probably would've won the biggest surprise award if those jerks didn't leak it on Twitter a couple days earlier, and if it hadn't been heavily rumored by many others. But don't be fooled by these awards. DKCR is THE JAM. Kid Icarus was a huge surprise because we didn't know it would be Project Sora's first game, or a 3DS launch title, or so damn beautiful. My only problem was I think biggest comeback AND/OR biggest surprise should've gone to Project Dust, for being Eric Chahi's first game since last millennium. Eric Chahi is god. Eric Chahi changed gaming more than most people realize. Even LIMBO reminded me of Chahi's Out of This World, for having no dialogue, no score, no health, no map, no HUD, no tutorial, and just being a beautiful cinematic platformer with awesome water and physics puzzles. The more I think about it, the more I want to give every award to Project Dust (without even knowing what it is), LIMBO, and Mortal Kombat. This really was a great year for every genre. I definitely found that out when we almost fought to the death debating these awards.


Teo (on 22 June 2010)

First of all, I love Zelda but Kirby > Zelda hands down. And as for Most innovative, it was LBP2. Kirby which it was 1% as innovative as LBP2. As said, terrible list.


O-D-C (on 22 June 2010)

I love how people who never played these games (I know u didn't) complain. Kinda silly.


PhantomLink (on 22 June 2010)

Good list :P


elmerion (on 22 June 2010)

Terrible, terrible list


senortaco (on 22 June 2010)

It cracks me up how ppl say the guys who ACTUALLY played the games on the demo floor don't know what the hell they are talking aboot!!! ....Anywho good list! From what I've read on the interweb you guys almost fall in lockstep, so I'm definitely interested in all the games listed. =D


tio_coyote (on 22 June 2010)

Rage>>> Bulletstorm, wth VGchartz!


Christian973 (on 22 June 2010)

I agree with this. Except for DKC is the best platformer.


ClassicGamingWizzz (on 22 June 2010)

where is rage? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>bulletstorm


Goddbless (on 22 June 2010)

Pretty good list but I think I would have to play Bulletstorm myself because it didn't impress me at all.


morenoingrato (on 22 June 2010)

kirby >>>>> dk? that's pretty much where I dissagree


naznatips (on 22 June 2010)

@ DirtyP Starcraft 2 wasn't even there, and as for the others on your list, they simply weren't as fun or original as the games we picked. Sorry your favorites didn't end up on there, but we picked the games we enjoyed the most and stood out the most, and that may not be everyone's favorite games on their respective platforms.


blunty51 (on 22 June 2010)

Was Echochrome 2 shown at E3? If so, that definitely would have deserved something for innovation.


Wandamaximoff (on 22 June 2010)

this just shows how few games where at E3 Halo reach is the best multiplayer game ever :D


Wagram (on 22 June 2010)

This is so full of fail titles.


forest-spirit (on 22 June 2010)

Great balls of yarn! Go Kirby!


mushroomboy5 (on 22 June 2010)

@dirtyp2002 I aint saying I agree with this list entirely... and I aint saying dkcr wasn't a surprise (although there were many rumours flying around, prior to e3, that retro were in fact working on a donkey kong title, so it kinda wasn't a surprise at all, more a confirmation of aforementioned rumours) but I'm pretty sure the kid icarus game for the 3ds was (like officially no question of doubt in my mind) a much bigger surprise to most people. Regardless of my own personal preferences, I'm pretty sure of that fact.


thekitchensink (on 22 June 2010)

Definitely agreed with Loaded. We debated for far too long when we should have been writing things up :P I believe Goldeneye was our runner-up for FPS. With regard to the best comeback, it only applied to games that have seen steady releases over the years of declining quality, only to have an excellent showing at E3. So Hot Pursuit easily fit into that category.


Fab_GS (on 22 June 2010)

@DirtyP2002 How did they "fail"? They actually played the games. So they know what was the best and what was not.


Shonen (on 22 June 2010)

I totally agree with this ...


hunter_alien (on 22 June 2010)

I agree with DirtyP, this list is flawed. No mention of DKCR or no tecnical award for Crysis 2... its a bit of a shame...


DirtyP2002 (on 22 June 2010)

no Gears, no Halo, no Fable ---> no competition. Sorry VGC, you failed. Biggest surprise should have been Donkey Kong Country. Best strategy game: Starcraft 2 Best 3rd person shooter: EASILY Gears of War 3 Best multiplayer experience: EASILY Halo Reach Best RPG: Fable III Biggest comeback: Twisted Metal or Donkey Kong Country Best FPS: Halo Reach I agree with Racing, Innovative, downloadable game, game of the show, Party Game and fighting game.


loadedstatement (on 22 June 2010)

@Dr.A.Peter.Nintendo Just by your username I can tell you are a bit biased =P Anyway, Metroid: Other M is great. I loved what I played of it at GDC and E3. Epic Mickey is also good and was a contender for Most Innovative with the ability to paint up or paint down your world. Mario Sports Mix is a bit generic to me and Wii Party will probably be more successful in the Party category. As for Goldeneye, a great game too. But there are TONS of FPS games out there this year. And Bulletstorm really amazing. I think you'll agree once you get your hands on it. To be honest, there were tons of games that deserved awards that did not get mentioned here. We debated for hours about who these awards should go to and in some cases, a lot of us were sad to not see some games win. But in the end, this is the list we came up with and we are pretty happy with it. That's not to say that the other games we played weren't tons of fun, as well.


iron_megalith (on 22 June 2010)

Is that a remake? I remember playing NFS: Hot pursuit on PS1... If it's a remake I hope they don't wreck my childhood memories of such a fantastic game.


Dr.A.Peter.Nintendo (on 22 June 2010)

Best 3rd person shooter should have been Metroid: Other M. And where is Epic Micky, Mario Sports Mix, and Golden Eye 007?


aragod (on 22 June 2010)

Pretty good picks imo, maybe except Bulletstorm and Wii Party (seriously?!). So many great games comming up, for me this seems like the most content packed E3 ever.


NudeGazelle (on 22 June 2010)

@Silver-Tiger In my opinion NFS:HP was infact the biggest come back of the show. The need for speed franchise has lacked a lot since Most Wanted and NFS was at it's peak in the HP days. I haven't purchased a need for speed since most wanted as i didn't see value in it, but now since the amazing trailer of HP this is a day 1 for me and a step into the future for the franchise.


novasonic (on 22 June 2010)

Best comeback should have been DKC Returns.


Ultr (on 22 June 2010)

wow what a fail, most innovative??? sheesh that would be LBP2 all the way.....


Dr.A.Peter.Nintendo (on 22 June 2010)

Man, this is Nintendo's biggest year yet!


younghavok (on 22 June 2010)

I really want to play Zelda, the visuals imo look remarkable and I cant wait to see them when they are finished. I wanna see the kind of environments Nintendo is going to to cook up with this one.


MattAnderson (on 22 June 2010)

I would have had Donkey Kong Country Returns as best platformer.


Cthulhu (on 22 June 2010)

Cool list and I agree with most. Replace Kirby with LBP2 though, anyway IMO


Silver-Tiger (on 22 June 2010)

Biggest Comeback is NOT Hot Pursuit. what's so big about that? They took the Need for Speed name and added Burnout elements. wow. Soo Innovative. Biggest Comeback was easily Kid Icarus. Fans have been demanding this game for decades now, and it's finally there.


CaptainHavok (on 22 June 2010)

Seriously guys, this took the dozen or so of us over three hours to decide on the entire awards lineup. The debating was fierce!


cromeros (on 21 June 2010)

Yeah.. Nintendo won on SW and Hardware.. And The Best Hardware???... Surely, 3DS.... 3DS >>>>>>>>>>> KINECT >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> PS MOVE... And... The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword... The nost wanted game... Second place... The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time 3D... :)


senseinobaka (on 21 June 2010)

@gvan I think thats really true for most of Nintendo's products. They market and design with user experience in mind and not so much visuals. It's like the whole 'playing is believing' mantra from E3 2006. The same can also be said of Dance Central, NFS: Hot Pursuit and Limbo... you really need to feel these games in action to understand why we think so highly of them. They dont seem completely impressive or unique in video, but once you try them you will love it.


FreeTalkLive (on 21 June 2010)

No DS or PSP but there was a 3DS so it is nice to see portables included.


naruball (on 21 June 2010)

Am I the only one who like Sorcery the most?


gvangoeverden (on 21 June 2010)

I guess the skyward sword is becoming like the 3ds, you just have to see it and feel it first hand to get it.